Greek Yogurt Tuna Salad Stuffed Peppers (No Mayo) (2024)

THIS RECIPE IS SPONSORED BY STARKIST SELECTS E.V.O.O.®

Greek Yogurt Tuna Salad Stuffed Peppers (No Mayo) are simple to make, requiring just basic pantry ingredients and about 10 minutes prep. StarKist Selects E.V.O.O.® Yellowfin Tunacreates a perfectly textured base, while Greek Yogurt and Avocado combine to make a dressing so creamy you won't miss the mayo!

Pin Greek Yogurt Tuna Salad Stuffed Peppers (No Mayo) for later!

If you follow along with @simplysissom on Instagram, you know that I recently conducted a poll about what types of recipes you would like me to focus on as we move through the "back to school" months of August/September. Overwhelmingly, you responded that you want EASY dinner recipes AND lunch box ideas, but for you! It's not hard to find endless amounts of kids’ lunchbox tutorials, but there's definitely a lack of focus on lunch ideas for grown-ups (you know, the people who are actually spending time shopping and packing them NIGHTLY).

Friends, I've got you.

Not only is today's recipe super simple to throw together, make-ahead friendly, AND a fun twist on a traditional classic... it's the type of lunch that makes you feel good about your life-choices (even after you've eaten it)!

Today, we talk Greek Yogurt Tuna Salad. Let's get the obvious out of the way, YES... this tuna salad is green. YES... I know that green shaded tuna may be initially off-putting. YES... you absolutely MUST start adding avocado to your tuna salad on a regular basis.

Originally, I wanted to call the recipe "Mayo Free Avocado Greek Yogurt Tuna Salad Stuffed Peppers", buuuuut it seemed a little wordy, so avocado lost its accolades. Forgive me?

This isn't your mama's tuna salad lunch-prep. We're going to load our Greek Yogurt Tuna Salad into crispy multi-colored baby bell peppers. They're cute, packable and most importantly ... we're replacing carb-heavy bread with veggies (you won't mind a bit, promise).

Let's do this, shall we?

How Do You Make Greek Yogurt Tuna Salad Stuffed Peppers (No Mayo)?

Sound fancy + wholesome, don't you think? In reality, it couldn't be easier.

First: Use a food processor or blender to make your mayo-free Avocado and Greek Yogurt dressing.

Next: Add 2 packs of StarKist Selects E.V.O.O.® Yellowfin Tunaand 1 pack of StarKist Selects E.V.O.O.® Yellowfin Tuna with Sun-dried Tomato to a mixing bowl.

Then: Pour the mayo-free avocado and Greek yogurt dressing into the mixing bowl.

Finally: Mix the sauce into the tuna and pile the finished product into crispy baby bell peppers.

FAQ'S ABOUT Greek Yogurt Tuna Salad Stuffed Peppers (No Mayo):

What Type of Tuna Should I Use To Make Greek Yogurt Tuna Salad (No Mayo)?:

I always use StarKist Selects E.V.O.O.® Yellowfin Tuna. It contains 3 recognizable ingredients (Yellowfin Tuna, E.V.O.O. and salt), is Wild Caught and has a really tender texture + mellow flavor (thanks to the cold-pressed E.V.O.O.). Trust me, you can taste the difference!

What type of yogurt should I use to make Greek Yogurt Tuna Salad (No Mayo)?:

Any type of Greek yogurt will work. Do make sure to purchase GREEK yogurt. Traditional yogurt cannot be subbed for this recipe. Your tuna salad will have a runny consistency.

I don't like bell peppers. Can I substitute a different veggie?

Of course! The bell peppers are just a suggestion, albeit a fantastic one 😜. You can load the finished tuna salad into a tortilla, enjoy it with carrot and celery sticks, crackers or even eat it straight from the bowl. The goal is flexibility.

Can Greek Yogurt Tuna Salad be made dairy-free?

It can, although you will have to change the name since dairy filled Greek Yogurt is a main component. Just double the amount of avocado and eliminate the yogurt all together. The result will still be delicious!

Is Greek Yogurt Tuna Salad Whole30 compliant?

Yes. It can be! To make this recipe Whole30 compliant, just eliminate the Greek Yogurt and double the amount of avocado.

Can Greek Yogurt Tuna Salad be made ahead of time?

You bet! Full disclosure, you may notice a bit of discoloration, but the taste isn't affected. I like to wait until the morning of to actually slice the baby bell peppers as they may lose some of their crispness if sliced too early.

Print

📖 Recipe

Let's Connect:

You can find Simply Sissom on Instagramwhere I share even more recipes (some that aren’t on the blog), behind the scenes pics and videos AND tips and tricks to make healthy eating realistic for your busy family.

Did you make this recipe? If you tried the recipe, I would love to see it, and have you share! Tag me @simplysissom using the hashtag #simplysissom.

Recipes Like Greek Yogurt Tuna Salad Stuffed Peppers (No Mayo):

Healthy Chicken Caesar Salad:

Deviled Egg Salad:

Easy Arugula Salad with Lemon Vinaigrette:

THIS RECIPE IS SPONSORED BY STARKIST SELECTS E.V.O.O.®